The church is willing to buy lights and air conditioners for the UES apartments losing sunlight and fresh air | Upper East Site, Redeemer Presbyterian Church
The church is willing to buy lights and air conditioners for the UES apartments losing sunlight and fresh air | Upper East Site, Redeemer Presbyterian Church

Rich Church tells Boxed-in UES Neighbors Losing Sunlight & Fresh Air: We’ll Get You Lights

Refusing to budge on plans to build an ostentatious 16-story-tall monument to opulence just three feet from the windows of their Upper East Side neighbors, Redeemer Presbyterian Church has come up with a solution for residents next-door set to lose most natural light and ventilation — albeit an embarrassingly selfish one.

“I remain very disappointed that you couldn’t accommodate them with the extra five feet,” said Community Board 8 member Michelle Birnbaum.

Apartments at 160 East 91st received plenty of air and light in January, before being blocked by construction | Upper East Site
Apartments at 160 East 91st received plenty of air and light in January, before being blocked by construction | Upper East Site

The board’s Zoning & Development Committee took the representatives from the wealthy church to task on Tuesday night — the first time the Redeemer has come before the board during the months-long David vs. Goliath fight — over their disappointment in the stubbornness of the church’s leadership and it’s less-than-neighborly steamrolling over its next-door neighbors.

“Listening to how welcoming and caring [you are] about your neighbors,” Community Board 8 First Vice Chair Valerie Mason wondered aloud, questioning why the impact on them “wasn’t uppermost in your thoughts when you were planning this building.”

The new church will be built at the property's edge with no light wells, blocking neighbors' windows | Redeemer Presbyterian Church East Side
The new church will be built at the property’s edge with no light wells, blocking neighbors’ windows | Redeemer Presbyterian Church East Side

There had never been a problem in the past because the previous apartment building that stood for decades at 150 East 91st Street, between Third and Lexington Avenues, had sprawling ‘light wells’ on its sides — recessed areas that gave its tenants and residents of the co-op next door plenty of light and air.

ALSO READ | DOT Rolls Out ‘Terrifying’ Truck-Share Rejected by UES Community Board

Redeemer Presbyterian church — which paid a staggering $29.5 million just for the property, despite a paltry membership of just over 1,000 congregants in a neighborhood with 230,000 residents — now says it is willing to pay for artificial lighting and roof-mounted air conditioners that won’t even provide fresh air to residents, however, neighbors will have to foot the added electric cost each month.

The previous building at 150 East 91st Street included a large light well (highlighted) | Apple Maps
The previous building at 150 East 91st Street included a large light well (highlighted) | Apple Maps

“When you consider all the energy that something like that will use, it’s contraindicated for times like these,” Birnbaum added, “I would imagine that the expense of that would be exorbitant assuming some electrical system which is very, very, very high costs.”

“We have no commitment to provide ongoing financial assistance,” said Bruce Terrell, Executive Director of Redeemer Presbyterian Church East Side.

In January, neighbors warned their apartments would be destroyed by church built just three feet from their windows | Upper East Site
In January, neighbors warned their apartments would be destroyed by church built just three feet from their windows | Upper East Site

At one point, when pressed by Mason, Terrell admitted that not only didn’t the Redeemer bother to do its due diligence regarding the buildings on opposite sides of the building, he noted that had they known about the difficulty with the neighbors — who were fighting to preserve nothing more than their access to natural light and fresh air — plans for the 91st Street church would have been scrapped.

“We can’t move the building and that’s really the practical issue of it,” explained Terrell, “Had we known had we known we needed to [give neighbors access to light and air] we wouldn’t have bought the property to begin with.”

“I’m sad it’s come to this,” said CB8 member Anthony Cohn, “I am very glad that you admit the problem, which is the problem of your own creation, sadly.”

An undated photo provides a birds eye view of church's construction | Redeemer Presbyterian Church
An undated photo provides a birds eye view of church’s construction | Redeemer Presbyterian Church

Only one resident from the co-op located at 160 East 91st Street showed up to Tuesday night’s meeting, sharing details about how Redeemer has been unwilling from the very start to alter their plans for the towering church building and resigned to their fate at the whims of the church’s unsympathetic leaders who control a financially-resourceful entity, which as a religious institution is not required to disclose how much money it has, much less where its funding comes from.

ALSO READ | You Can Install Random Shit on UES Sidewalks and It Will Stay If You Don’t Get Caught

“In addition to the cost of the equipment and the installation, we definitely are incurring the [cost of] management [and] supervision,” said Meenakshi Rao, a representative from the co-op, “If you could reconsider that, it would be helpful.”

Unlike other non-profit entities that still file returns with the IRS, churches are not required to report any revenue or spending information to the government and serve as untaxed financial black holes.

The church has only 10 floors despite being 16-stories tall | Redeemer Presbyterian Church
The new church has only 10 floors despite being 16-stories tall | Redeemer Presbyterian Church

Upper East Site inquired as to the cost of membership at Redeemer Presbyterian Church, but did not receive a response.

“The building lacks humility,” Cohn added, “It is not architecturally a good neighbor.”

As many committee members noted, the massive and extravagant 158-foot-tall church lined with gold trim and adorned with a giant cross, is out of character with the block, while Redeemer’s actions also fly in the face of its so-called mission of ‘giving back,’ which was peddled by several parishioners who spoke in favor of the church’s plan.

The new church will be built at the property's edge with no light wells, blocking neighbors' windows | Redeemer Presbyterian Church East Side
The new church will be built at the property’s edge with no light wells, blocking neighbors’ windows | Redeemer Presbyterian Church East Side

“As a stay-at-home mom, one who utilizes that play-and-learn co-op for my two toddlers, it can be an isolating place. I can’t wait to have a space for our family to meet to play throughout the week,” said parishioner Bridget Landon, speaking about her family’s desires while neglecting to mention those whose homes are now shut in by concrete, “I love knowing that our family will have a physical church space to call home.”

“I’m excited … how there will be a permanent space that uniquely allows me to meet others from my neighborhood from backgrounds that are very different from mine,” explained Bridget’s husband Rob, ignoring the fact that all those “very different” people he meets all have one big thing in common.

Church leaders refused to give up five feet of their sprawling space to accommodate neighbors | Redeemer Presbyterian Church
Church leaders refused to give up five feet of their sprawling space to accommodate neighbors | Redeemer Presbyterian Church

Following the testimonials from Redeemer congregants, Community Board 8 member Elizabeth Rose brought up burning questions on many peoples’ minds.

“When did you learn that the proposed building would have the impact that it will have on the adjacent departments? How do you feel about that? What would you say to those individuals who are being affected? And how does this fit with your spiritual and religious beliefs?” Rose asked the parishioners still in the meeting.

Only one congregant would come forward to give a response.

Redeemer is building its new church flush with the building next door, blocking sunlight | Upper East Site
Redeemer is building its new church flush with the building next door, blocking sunlight | Upper East Site

“I feel that my church has handled a really difficult situation very well. It has been something that we weren’t happy about” explained Kimberly Hunt, “but at the same time, I do believe that — and I hope that — the benefits of what we bring will outweigh some of this.”

When questioned by a member of the public about security and the possibility of a police presence, given the impending influx of hundreds of people onto the quiet block to utilize the massive new church’s services — as well as the church-affiliated non-profit that will be leasing several floors of the building — Redeemer’s leadership were once again solely-focused on themselves.

Redeemer has refused to accommodate their neighbors requests for space to allow light and air | Upper East Site
Redeemer has refused to accommodate their neighbors requests for space to allow light and air | Upper East Site

“We have two security guards that are there every Sunday, that literally are wanding people [with metal detectors] as they as they walk in, so we are committed to keeping things safe for the neighborhood and certainly for our congregants as well,” Terrell said, without explaining about how the church would be keeping the neighborhood safe.

CB8 member Marco Tamayo then scolded the Redeemer’s architect for ignoring the environmental impacts of the building, which is not designed to be sustainable or conserve energy.

“As a professional, you have an ethical or moral obligation to preserve this planet to reduce carbon emissions,” Tamayo said, “More carbon emissions you emit, the poor quality the air is in the neighborhood. This is a serious problem for me.”

The opulent new church is already nearing the rooflines of neighboring buildings | Upper Easy Site
The opulent new church is already nearing the rooflines of neighboring buildings | Upper Easy Site

“It does comply with every energy code requirement of the building that was set up by the state in the city,” Terrell fired back, confusing compliance with the limits of the law with that of human decency — a recurring theme throughout the meeting.

ALSO READ | FCC Puts the Brakes on Link5G Tower Rollout Until Reviews are Complete

Unwilling to recognize that the ‘right thing to do’ and ‘what the law allows’ are not always the same — despite the fact that a set of ethical and moral principles are what churches preach to their followers — Redeemer has repeatedly pointed to the new building being constructed ‘as-of-right,’ meaning no special permission is needed.

Most windows next door to the new church are already blocked by the concrete exterior wall | Upper East Site
Most windows next door to the new church are already blocked by the concrete exterior wall | Upper East Site

At the building on Wednesday morning, most of the windows next door have been ensconced by the new church, which is already nearing the 85’ roofline of its neighbor despite Redeemer’s characterization Tuesday night as having only four stories built.

“I’m disappointed. I understand what the law is. People do what the law requires,” said Mason, “I just don’t understand why that thought process wasn’t really at the inception of this project in dealing with your neighbors.”

For updates around the clock, follow us on InstagramTwitter and Facebook

Suggest a Correction
——
Copyright 2023 Upper East Site. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, rewritten, broadcast, or redistributed.

Link5G Towers Must Pass Historic Preservation and Environmental Reviews, Says FCC | Gabriel Sandoval/THE CITY

FCC Puts the Brakes on Link5G Tower Rollout Until Reviews are Complete

Actor Julia Fox's brother has been indicted on 17 counts in connection with a ghost gun parts and drugs found in his UES apartment | Upper East Site, @juliafox, NYPD

Julia Fox’s ‘Mad Scientist’ Brother Indicted on 17 Counts UES Ghost Gun & Drug Case