Papaya King’s Future Uncertain After 90 Years Amid Lawsuit, Demolition Plans

Papaya King's future uncertain after 90 years amid lawsuit, demolition plans | Upper East Site
Papaya King's future uncertain after 90 years amid lawsuit, demolition plans | Upper East Site

MANHATTAN – The future is uncertain for Papaya King— the legendary New York City frankfurter purveyor is facing the end of the line. It’s longtime home at the corner of Third Avenue and East 86th Street on the Upper East Side, where it has been slinging hot dogs and tropical drinks for ninety years, is set for demolition.

This is far from your typical case of a developer muscling out a neighborhood institution— a lawsuit making its way through the courts paints a strange picture of what’s happening behind the scenes at the popular hot dog shop.

ALSO READ | Zesty Pizzeria Evicted from UES Storefront by NYC Sheriff after Court Battle

Grab & Go Convenience LLC, a formerly-contracted operator of the East 86th Street and Third Avenue Papaya King location, is accused by the previous landlord— and later the building’s current owner— of breaking into the shop and resuming operations after the lease was terminated in 2020, according to court documents.

Papaya King's future uncertain after 90 years amid lawsuit, demolition plans | Upper East Site
Papaya King’s future uncertain after 90 years amid lawsuit, demolition plans | Upper East Site

The plaintiffs in the lawsuit repeatedly describe the current Papaya King operators as trespassers who refused to vacate the premises, despite being offered ‘monetary incentives.’

Cohen's Optical and the Children's Place also occupied the building slated for demolition | Upper East Site
Cohen’s Optical and the Children’s Place also occupied the building slated for demolition | Upper East Site

This week, plans were filed with the NYC Department of Buildings to demolish the structure housing Papaya King and three other now-vacant storefronts, though it’s not clear what will be built on the bustling Upper East Side corner.

ALSO READ | Wankel’s Hardware says Goodbye after 125 Years on the Upper East Side

Details of the filing were first reported by Nick Garber at UES Patch.

Congresswoman Carolyn Maloney eventually chimed in on the demolition plans in a tweet, declaring “Papaya King is an East Side institution that has served generations of NYers since 1932.”

Congresswoman Carolyn Maloney laments demolition plans filed for Papaya King's building | Carolyn Maloney's Office
Congresswoman Carolyn Maloney laments demolition plans filed for Papaya King’s building | Carolyn Maloney’s Office

“NYC has lost far too many of its historic eateries. Let’s not lose another small businesses that helped shape this City,” Maloney added, posing in front of the UES fixture with one of their famous dogs and a drink in hand.

Representatives for Papaya King could not be reached.

For updates around the clock, follow us on InstagramTwitter and Facebook

Police are searching for the suspect who menaced and spewed an anti-gay slur at two men on the UES | NYPD

Hammer-weilding Suspect Menaces Men on the UES, Spews Anti-Gay Slur: NYPD

Azsia Johnson's ex-boyfriend Isaac Argro is charged with her murder | Kevin RC Wilson/FNTV

Ex-Boyfriend Arrested in UES Murder of Young Mother Azsia Johnson