Photo shows a green sign featuring white writing reading 'Wonder.'
If you're an Upper East Side resident who likes $34 steaks pre-cooked in the Garden State, Wonder is the place for you | Upper East Site

New UES Restaurant ‘Wonder’ Serves Food Pre-Cooked in New Jersey


The time has almost arrived for the official grand opening of Wonder’s new Carnegie Hill restaurant. The company, valued at $3.5 billion, is the mashup of big tech and big food that no one asked for, bringing reheated eats first cooked an hour away in Parsippany, New Jersey, to hungry Upper East Side residents starting February 6th.

As Upper East Site first reported last fall, the big-money startup built a single brand-new restaurant — not the nearly two dozen it claimed — in the former Panera Bread location at 120 East 86th Street between Lexington and Park Avenues, which began fulfilling orders as part of its soft launch last month and whose signage was installed Wednesday.

Photo shows an angled view of a beige brick and glass storefront with a green sign featuring white writing reading 'Wonder' and 'Pickup' and 'Delivery.' A bike is parked in front.
Wonder is located at 120 East 86th Street between Lexington and Park Avenues | Upper East Site

With its own twist on the sketchy practice of using ‘virtual restaurants‘ — brands that only exist on delivery platforms like Grubhub, DoorDash and Uber Eats, with no physical presence, obscuring the identity of the City- or State- licensed establishment preparing the food — the restaurant’s sub-brands are not marketed as being part of Wonder on delivery-apps.

Wonder boasts 22 menus under mostly new identities while also leveraging the name value of celebrity chefs including Food Network stars Marcus Samuelsson, Michael Symon and Marc Murphy.

Photo shows two rows of colorful paper menus.
Wonder offers 22 different menus, including in-house brands and others associated with celebrity chefs | Upper East Site

“Wonder has partnered with a number of different Michelin star chefs, award-winning chefs, people that hold a lot of weight in terms of their brand image and the food that they would put out in the world,” explained Wonder’s anonymous spokesperson. “Wonder actually worked directly with them to recreate menus that they serve in their own restaurants.”

ALSO READ | Your Favorite UES Restaurant on Seamless Probably Does Not Exist

Bobby Flay Steak, a Wonder menu based on the real Atlantic City restaurant owned by famed Iron Chef Bobby Flay, promises “bold flavors and premium cuts from one of the country’s best chefs.” 

Photo shows two men with light complexions. The one on the left is older with grey hair in a blue suit with a light blue tie and the other has brown hair and is wearing a blue chefs coat.
Wonder features a menu for Bobby Flay Steak, a restaurant owned by Chef Bobby Flay (right), seen with former Secretary of State John Kerry (left) | U.S. Department of State

What Wonder fails to mention is that your steak will be par-cooked at their commissary, which the company tells Upper East Site is located in Parsippany, New Jersey, then delivered to the Upper East Side, where it will eventually be reheated or ‘finished’ as Wonder calls it, by employees dubbed ‘line cooks’ — who are only required to have one or more “years of experience working in a fast-paced restaurant environment or a related field” — using a TurboChef oven, which blasts food with heated forced air and microwaves.


When asked where the food is prepared, Wonder staff tells customers it is made in-house in their Upper East Side restaurant, never mentioning New Jersey.

Composite shows screenshots from a job listing for a Wonder Line Cook.
Wonder’s ‘Line Cooks’ are not required to have any kitchen or restaurant experience | Greenhouse via Google, Composite by Upper East Site

“I just asked him [the Wonder staffer] where it was prepared, and he said in the back,” a customer told Upper East Site.

A Wonder spokesperson who communicated with Upper East Site under the condition of anonymity, which is unusual for a company seeking to promote its new restaurant, said that Wonder workers at the Parsippany commissary cooking the steaks sous-vide style — placing the meat in a sealed bag submerged in hot water until cooked to the proper temperature — is no different than a local Upper East Side eatery doing so on-premises, failing to take into account that Wonder’s par-cooked food is driven across state lines.

Photo shows a sous vide water warmer in a metal basin with several sealed bags full of chicken.
Sous-vide is a technique in which meat is placed in vacuum-sealed plastic bags and cooked in temperature-controlled water | Envato Elements

“A lot of restaurants will do a lot of this par-cooking hours in advance of them actually heating up a meal,” Wonder’s spokesperson explained, ignoring the part about it being done so far away in Parsippany. “Even in New York, [local restaurants] will sous-vide the steaks and then char them and fire them when they’re made to order later that night.”

Upper East Site inquired whether Wonder believed its customers would be as receptive to their ‘Fast-Fine dining’ concept if they knew their food was prepared in New Jersey and reheated using a TurboChef oven, like those used to toast your footlong sub at Subway restaurants, but by Wonder’s own near-minimum wage workers. 

The anonymous spokesperson deflected our question and explained that Wonder’s TurboChef ovens were improved over the off-the-shelf product used at all other restaurants by adjusting the hardware and adding software to put the needed sear on its steaks in five minutes. 

Photo shows a Subway restaurant in a food court with a TurboChef oven, a bulky countertop cooking machine, circled in red.
Subway sandwich restaurants use TurboChef ovens to toast their subs | TAC PlazaMaster, highlighted by Upper East Site

“They’ve spent years designing and redesigning that oven by tweaking the hardware and actually building software on top of it to the point where they are able to char a pizza, where they are able to create that great-tasting steak.”

Wonder did not provide any evidence to support its claims. TurboChef did not immediately respond to our inquiry about whether their ovens could be modified in such a fashion; however, a customer service representative for the company said it was possible to reprogram their machines.

When we asked why Wonder doesn’t see it as deceptive to list its brands on third-party apps without mentioning they are not actual restaurants, or at the very least, affiliated with Wonder, the anonymous spokesperson compared it to the extensive use of virtual restaurants on other delivery platforms, questioning whether those are misleading as well.

Photo shows  wonder employee behind a small counter with a pass through window to the kitchen next to him. A green door next to the worker is labeled 'Kitchen.'
A single Wonder employee assists customers and distributes meals but does not accept food orders | Upper East Site

When we told them yes, it was, in fact, deceptive for a deli to present itself as 25 different and unique restaurants; the spokesperson offered no rebuttal and blamed “semantics” over what actually constitutes a restaurant.

Despite describing itself as a ‘new food hall,’ there is no food hall inside 120 East 86th Street, and customers cannot even place an order with the worker stationed inside the restaurant. Instead, the employee is only there to help you place an order on a kiosk or through the company’s app. However, Wonder will accept cash as payment in-store in accordance with New York City law.

Photo shows three tablets on a beige counter with green cabinets underneath. A colorful painting is on the wall above the tablets.
Customers are required to order from the three touchscreen kiosks or download the Wonder app | Upper East Site

There are four small tables with booth and chair seating inside the new Upper East Side restaurant, with a counter and stools against the front window for dining as well.

When Upper East Site asked one customer what he thought about Wonder, his only complaint was that the portion size was too small for the cost of the dishes he received.

When informed that his food was first prepared in New Jersey before arriving on the Upper East Side, the customer was surprised but said, “We want it to be fresh — as long as it tastes fresh.”

Photo shows a small dining area with green walls and mirrors hung to make the space seem larger.
Wonder’s dining room has four tables with additional stools and counter space against the front window | Upper East Site

Upper East Site requested a tour of Wonder’s Upper East Side kitchen to observe their food operations in the neighborhood. Instead, we were offered the opportunity to sample their food par-cooked in New Jersey and shipped to Carnegie Hill for finishing.

ALSO READ | Dirty Warehouse Hosting Fake Restaurants Expanding to the Upper East Side

We declined. 

Representatives for Bobby Flay, Michael Symon, Marcus Samuelsson and Marc Murphy did not respond to an inquiry from Upper East Site.

Follow Upper East Site on InstagramX, Threads & Facebook

Suggest a Correction
Copyright 2024 Upper East Site. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, rewritten, broadcast, or redistributed.

Composite shows a close up of the restaurant name 'Amarena' written in burgundy on a beige awning with thin blue stripes. Inset is a photo of a man with dark hair and a light complexion in a black shirt.

Celebrity Chef Medina Triples-Down on the UES with New Upscale Italian Spot ‘Amarena’

Photo shows a glass display case with a white shelf at the bottom filled with illicit cannabis products.

UES Smoke Shops Raided, 44+ Pounds of Illicit Products Seized: Sheriff