Two Boots Pizza Coming Back to UES after Four Year Hiatus

Two Boots opening new pizzeria at East 65th Street and Second Avenue/Upper East Site
Two Boots opening new pizzeria at East 65th Street and Second Avenue/Upper East Site

MANHATTAN – An old Upper East Side favorite for pizza is coming back to the neighborhood in a big way after a long hiatus. Two Boots pizza is planning to open a new shop in Lenox Hill nearly four years after their Yorkville shop closed down.

Two Boots’ new location on the Upper East Side is set to open at the northwest corner of East 65th Street and Second Avenue, in the space formerly belonging to Fellan Florist, which has been vacant since 2020. 

Two Boots opening new pizzeria at East 65th Street and Second Avenue/Upper East Site
Two Boots opening new pizzeria at East 65th Street and Second Avenue/Upper East Site

Last summer, Winick Realty Group announced Two Boots had signed a lease for the pizzeria at 1243 Second Avenue, and this just month, ‘coming soon’ signs were spotted in the windows, announcing their big return to the Upper East Side.

ALSO READ | Highly-Anticipated New Speakeasy Disguised as Locksmith Now Open

If you’ve lived in the neighborhood a while, you probably remember Two Boots colorful yellow sign above their longtime pizzeria at the southwest corner of East 84th Street and Second Avenue. 

Two Boots opening new pizzeria at East 65th Street and Second Avenue/Upper East Site
Two Boots opening new pizzeria at East 65th Street and Second Avenue/Upper East Site

Best known for the Cajun-Italian fusion of flavors, two popular pizza pies include the popular Mr. Pink, named after the character from the film Reservoir Dogs— topped with creole chicken, plum tomatoes, fresh garlic and mozzarella— and the Cleopatra Jones, named after the 1973 blaxploitation film crime fighter— featuring sweet Italian sausage, roasted peppers, red onions and mozzarella.

Two Boots pizza offers a variety of vegan, veggie and meat slices
Two Boots pizza offers a variety of vegan, veggie and meat slices/Dash Pellegrini

At the time, Two Boots was one of the few pizzerias in the neighborhood to offer vegan pizza, starting with the ‘V for Vegan.’ Introduced in 2011, it features artichokes, red onions, shiitake mushrooms, sweet red pepper pesto, basil pesto and Daiya non-dairy cheese.

Two Boots' original pizza location at Second Avenue and East 85th Street closed in 2018/Google
Two Boots’ original pizza location at Second Avenue and East 85th Street closed in 2018/Google

That Yorkville location would close down in 2018 and eventually become a Williamsburg Pizza.

An early adopter in the vegan pizza space, the number of plant-based pies at Two Boots has grown to nine— including vegan versions of their the Mr. Pink and the Cleopatra Jones.

ALSO READ | Agata & Valentina Close to Opening New Market on the Upper East Side

Even the name ‘Two Boots’ is derived from the Cajun-Italian fusion, and the the boot-like shapes of Italy and the state of Louisiana. 

Two Boots pizza offers a variety of vegan, veggie and meat slices
Two Boots pizza offers a variety of vegan, veggie and meat slices/Dan Cunningham

It’s not yet clear when the new Two Boots pizzeria will open at East 65th Street and Second Avenue on the UES, but if you cant wait you can head down to the closest shop, located in the East Village.

Upper East Site has reached out to the company for more information and is waiting to hear back. We’ll update this article accordingly.

For updates around the clock, follow us on InstagramTwitter and Facebook

People enjoy cocktails inside SoHo’s Lure Fishbar, Feb. 28, 2022

Mayor Eric Adams Lifts Restaurant Vaccine Checks. Some Owners Might Keep Them Anyway

Surveillance video shows the black car slam into the SUV (top right) outside Third Ave. Garden/Obtained by Upper East Site

SEE IT: Out-of-Control Car Crashes into Upper East Side Deli Going Backwards