A 37-year-old FDNY Firefighter was charged with criminal mischief, police say | NYPD, Chabad Israel Center
A 37-year-old FDNY Firefighter was charged with criminal mischief, police say | NYPD, Chabad Israel Center

FDNY Firefighter Arrested for Smashing Upper East Side Sukkah: NYPD

The NYPD announced Friday that an FDNY firefighter has been arrested in a disturbing case of vandalism targeting a sukkah constructed outside of an Upper East Side Jewish center, which police say had been smashed and urinated inside.

Detectives say 37-year-old Marty Party is the man caught on camera back on October 8th repeatedly kicking the sukkah — a hut used for dining during the Jewish holiday of Sukkot — set up by the Chabad Israel Center on East 92nd Street near the corner of Second Avenue.

Surveillance video caught the suspect not only smashing the sukka, but urinating in it as well, police say | Chabad Israel Center
Surveillance video caught the suspect not only smashing the sukkah, but urinating in it as well, police say | Chabad Israel Center

Police say he even relieved himself inside the structure, desecrating the holy space. A good samaritan was seen in surveillance video released by the Chabad Israel Center pleading with the suspect to stop the destruction.

Plexiglass on the side of the sukka was smashed | Chabad Israel Center
Plexiglass on the side of the sukkah was smashed | Chabad Israel Center

Firefighter Party — who was arrested and charged with criminal mischief — had been identified as the suspect by multiple Upper East Site readers last month, shortly after we published surveillance images of the suspect released by police last month. We instructed them to contact Crime Stoppers.

ALSO READ | Ice Menorah Smashed In Second Holiday Attack on UES Jewish Center

“Sadly, this is very unsurprising to anyone who knows him,” said one tipster, “[Crime Stoppers] said multiple people had sent in his info.”

FDNY Firefighter Marty Party was charged with criminal mischief, police say | NYPD
FDNY Firefighter Marty Party was charged with criminal mischief, police say | NYPD

Marty Party was not charged with a hate crime despite the incident’s initial investigation as such. A law enforcement source tells Upper East Site the suspect did not appear to be acting out of hate.

“He in fact damaged the structure, however, we do not believe there was any racial bias behind it,” the source explained, noting that Party may have been intoxicated.

Plexiglass on the side of the sukka was smashed | Chabad Israel Center
Plexiglass on the side of the sukka was smashed | Chabad Israel Center

Rabbi Uriel Vigler, who leads the Chabad Israel Center, told Upper East Site that they “thank the NYPD for doing a superb job investigating this crime and we are glad it has been resolved.”

“In the spirit of Chanukah,” Rabbi Vigler says, “we urge everyone to do their part in illuminating the world by doing a good deed today. This is the most effective tool we have in our possession.”

ALSO READ | Elderly Man Assaulted in Random Upper East Side Attack: NYPD

It has been a difficult three months for Chabad Israel Center, in addition to the vandalism of its sukkah in October, a beautiful menorah carved from ice for Hanukkah celebrations this week was smashed and left in pieces on the sidewalk in what appears to be an intentional act, though unconnected to the prior incident.

As for Mr. Party, Upper East Site tried to contact him through Instagram shortly after readers came forward identifying him as the suspect, however, his account has since been removed. A Twitter account in his name has also been deleted.

Upper East Site attempted to contact Marty Party via Instagram in November
Upper East Site attempted to contact Marty Party via Instagram in November

The FDNY says Marty Party has been suspended from the job for four weeks, which is the maximum allowed. However, they note he could be sidelined longer as his criminal case proceeds.

Party is based out of a Manhattan firehouse, according to the FDNY, but was not on-duty at the time of the incident.

“Hopefully now he gets the help he needs,” a tipster added.

For updates around the clock, follow us on InstagramTwitter and Facebook

Comments are closed.

One Comment

  1. The fact that he has a self-less job where he goes into fires to save people he doesn’t know, yet he destroys a religious symbol of people he doesn’t know is a contradiction of who he is. I would suspend him for a month, with no pay and he has to take classes to learn about the Jewish religion. What did Jews ever do to this man with the very dumb name?

An elderly man was assaulted on the Upper East Side in what police say was a random attack

Elderly Man Assaulted in Random Upper East Side Attack: NYPD

Mulchfest Christmas tree drop off location in Carl Schurz Park | Upper East Site

Easily Recycle Your Christmas Tree as Mulchfest Returns to the Upper East Side